"Internet nexus of cultural Judaism" — Examiner.com
I score should be 5. All of his grandparents were Jews.
4 Jewish grandparents doesn't necessarily get you I 5. Especially not with a Catholic conversion in there.
Ok, fair point, but there's a difference between someone who fears anti-semitism in 19th or 20th century Europe, makes the conversion by necessity, and for example a cretin anchorman from the US who renounces his Jewish roots and finally finds out that he has a "personal relationship with Jesus".
Oy vey! Do they get a 5 if they publicly convert, but covertly observe the Sabbath, Pesach, Yom Kippur, etc. by becoming Seventh Day Adventists? Personally grew up with Jews (Black) who did this.